Committee reports

Audit committee report

This report is provided by the audit committee appointed for FY16 in compliance with the Companies Act 71 of 2008, as amended. The committee’s operation is guided by a detailed charter informed by the Companies Act and King III, and approved by the board.

The committee has executed its duties and responsibilities for the review period in line with its terms of reference relating to the group’s accounting, internal control, external auditing and financial reporting practices.

Structure

The committee comprises three independent non-executive directors.

The chairman of the audit committee is not the chairman of the board. The following directors served on the committee in FY16:

  • Rob Nisbet (chairman)
  • Khotso Mokhele
  • Yunus Suleman.

Biographical details of committee members appear on pages 11 and 12. Fees paid to committee members are outlined in the remuneration report on page 101.

The year under review

External audit

The committee, among other matters:

  • Nominated Ernst & Young Inc to shareholders for appointment as the external auditor, and Warren Kinnear as the designated auditor, for the financial year ended 30 September 2016. It ensured that the appointment complied with all applicable legal and regulatory requirements, and that the auditor and designated auditor are accredited by the JSE Limited
  • Approved the external audit engagement letter, plan and budgeted audit fees payable to the external auditor. Fees paid to the auditor are detailed in note 4.1 of the group annual financial statements
  • Reviewed the audit, evaluated the effectiveness of the auditor and its independence, and evaluated the external auditor’s internal quality control procedures
  • Obtained an annual written statement from the auditor that its independence was not impaired
  • Considered the reports of the external auditor on the group’s systems of internal control, including financial controls
  • Determined the nature and extent of all non-audit services provided by the external auditor and pre-approved all non-audit services to be undertaken
  • Obtained assurances from the external auditor that adequate accounting records were being maintained
  • Considered whether any reportable irregularities were identified and reported by the external auditor in terms of the Auditing Profession Act 26 of 2005, and determined that there were none
  • Nominated the external auditor and designated independent auditor for the company.

Independence of the external auditor

The audit committee is satisfied that Ernst & Young Inc is independent of the group after considering the following factors:

  • Representations made by Ernst & Young Inc to the audit committee
  • The auditor does not, except as external auditor or in rendering permitted non-audit services, receive any remuneration or other benefit from the company
  • The auditor’s independence was not impaired by any consultancy, advisory or other work undertaken
  • The auditor’s independence was not prejudiced by any previous appointment as auditor
  • Criteria specified for independence by the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors and international regulatory bodies.

Financial statements

In respect of the financial statements, the committee:

  • Confirmed the going concern requirement as the basis of preparing interim and annual financial statements
  • Reviewed compliance with the financial conditions of loan covenants and determined that the capital and debt facilities of the group are adequate
  • Examined and reviewed the interim and annual financial statements, as well as all financial information disclosed to the public prior to submission to and approval by the board
  • Ensured the annual financial statements fairly present the financial position of the company and group at the end of the financial year and the results of operations and cash flows for that financial year, and considered the basis on which the company and group were determined to be a going concern
  • Considered accounting treatments, significant unusual transactions and accounting judgements
  • Considered the appropriateness of accounting policies adopted and any changes
  • Reviewed the external auditor’s audit report
  • Reviewed the representation letter on the group financial statements signed by management
  • Considered any problems identified and reviewed any significant legal and tax matters that could have a material impact on the financial statements
  • Met separately with management and external audit to review and discuss the annual financial statements
  • Received and considered reports from the internal auditors.

Internal controls and internal audit

For internal controls and internal audit, including forensic audit, the committee:

  • Reviewed and approved the internal audit charter and annual audit plan and evaluated the independence, effectiveness and performance of the internal audit function and compliance with its charter
  • Considered reports of the internal auditor on the group’s systems of internal control including financial controls, business risk management and maintaining effective internal control systems
  • Received assurance that proper and adequate accounting records were maintained and that the systems safeguarded assets against unauthorised use or disposal
  • Reviewed significant issues raised by internal and forensic audit processes and the adequacy of corrective action in response to significant internal and forensic audit findings
  • Assessed the performance of the internal audit function and found it satisfactory
  • The committee confirms it has no reason to believe there were any material breakdowns in the design and operating effectiveness of internal financial controls during the period that have not been addressed or are not being addressed by management.

In terms of risk management and information technology relevant to its functions, the committee:

  • Reviewed the group’s policies on risk assessment and management, including fraud risks and information technology risks as they relate to financial reporting and the going concern assessment, and found them sound
  • Considered and reviewed the findings and recommendations of the risk and sustainability committee.

In respect of sustainability issues, the committee:

  • Considered the findings and recommendations of the risk and sustainability committee
  • Met with senior management to consider findings on assurance, and made appropriate enquiries from management. Through this process, it has received the necessary assurances that material disclosures are reliable and do not conflict with financial information.

For legal and regulatory requirements, to the extent that these may have an impact on the financial statements, the committee:

  • Reviewed, with management, legal matters that could have a material impact on the group
  • Reviewed, with the company’s internal counsel, the adequacy and effectiveness of the group’s procedures to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory responsibilities
  • Monitored concerns on accounting matters, internal audit, internal accounting controls, contents of the financial statements, potential violations of the law and questionable accounting or auditing matters
  • Considered reports provided by management, internal auditor and external auditor on compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.

In terms of coordinating assurance activities, the committee reviewed the plans and work outputs of the external and internal auditors and concluded these were adequate to address all significant financial risks facing the business.

Chief financial officer expertise and experience

The committee also considered the expertise, resources and experience of the chief financial officer, Noel Doyle, and concluded these were appropriate. Biographical details appear on page 12.

Company secretary

In terms of section 3.84 of the JSE Listings Requirements, the committee considered the competence, qualifications and experience of Thiroshnee Naidoo to hold the position of company secretary and concluded these were appropriate. Biographical details appear on page 13.

All directors have unlimited access to the services of the company secretary, who is responsible to the board for ensuring proper corporate governance principles are applied.

The company secretary is also responsible for ensuring the proper administration of proceedings and matters relating to the board, the company and shareholders in line with applicable legislation and procedures. She is also responsible for director training and induction, as well as the annual board evaluation.

The committee confirms that the company secretary maintains an arm’s length relationship with the board and directors, taking into account that the company secretary is not a director of the company and is not related to any of the directors.

Annual financial statements

Following its review of the annual financial statements of Tiger Brands Limited for the year ended 30 September 2016, the committee believes that, in all material respects, these comply with the relevant provisions of the Companies Act and IFRS and fairly present the consolidated and separate financial position of the company at that date and the results of its operations and cash flows for that year. The committee has also satisfied itself of the integrity of the remainder of this integrated annual report 2016.

Having achieved its objectives, the audit committee recommended the annual financial statements and integrated annual report for approval by the board. The board has since approved the annual financial statements and integrated annual report 2016, which will be open for discussion at the upcoming annual general meeting.

On behalf of the committee

Robert Nisbet
Chairman

22 November 2016

Social, ethics and transformation committee report

Terms of engagement

The board delegates oversight of the company’s ethics and transformation management to this committee, through which the CEO is held accountable for the company’s ethics and transformation performance. As a statutory committee of the company and its subsidiaries, the committee fulfils its duties in terms of sections 72(4) and (5) of the Companies Act 2008 and regulation 43 of the Companies Regulations 2011. Its activities are also guided by King III.

Together with the risk and sustainability committee, it ensures the company conducts its business sustainably and ethically by developing and reviewing policies and practices to guide Tiger Brands’ approach to social and ethics-related challenges as per its terms of reference.

Its purpose is to drive the Tiger Brands approach to good corporate citizenship by ensuring the group’s activities have a positive impact on its many stakeholders including consumers, employees, communities, shareholders and members of the public, and to report on this to shareholders annually at the AGM.

As a committee of the board, it assists the board in discharging its duties and makes recommendations to the board on social and economic development, sustainability, ethics, good corporate citizenship, environment, health and public safety, consumer-related matters, stakeholder management, issues management as applicable, and labour and employment issues.

During the review period, the committee’s terms of reference were revised and updated to outline its comprehensive remit.

Membership and attendance

Member Designation Attendance  
Maya Makanjee Chair, non-executive director 3/3  
Bheki Sibiya Deputy chair of Tiger Brands board, non-executive director 3/3  
Makhup Nyama Non-executive director 3/3  
Lawrence Mac Dougall Ex officio member, CEO 1/1  

Relevant executive managers attend committee meetings as required:

Executive management Portfolio Attendance  
Patrick Sithole Supply chain, health, safety and environment 3/3  
Tswelo Kodisang Human resources 3/3  
Bridgitte Backman Corporate affairs and sustainability 3/3  
Thiroshnee Naidoo Legal and compliance 3/3  

Outline of activities

The committee’s oversight role has matured to ensure the group plays a strong corporate citizenship role primarily in South Africa. Since May 2016, and after establishing an operational ethics committee, a comprehensive ethics report is tabled and discussed at meetings.

For the review period, the committee:

  • Monitored the company’s activities against international and local standards:
    - The 10 principles in the United Nations Global Compact
    - Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) recommendations on corruption
    - Employment Equity Act No 55 1998, as amended
    - BBBEE and agri-sector code five-year plan compliance and progress against objectives approved by the board in July 2015
  • Reviewed its framework of policies and processes to manage activities against ethical and social standards
  • Met with the chairs of audit and risk and sustainability committees to review focus areas and any overlaps in the remit of these committees
  • Monitored progress on the FTSE4Good index, where Tiger Brands is a top 30 performer
  • Monitored progress on a key public-private partnership (a first for the company), after Tiger Brands signed a memorandum of understanding with the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries to develop black smallholder farmers
  • Reviewed the group’s carbon disclosure submission for CDP
  • Reviewed and discussed the role of the newly formed operational ethics committee
  • Reviewed progress against socio-economic development plans and processes:
    - CSI strategy, key performance indicators and objectives
    - Engaged interns for the Great South African Cookbook, in partnership with the Nelson Mandela Foundation
    - Tiger Brands Foundation progress report. The Foundation is on track to deliver its 40 millionth meal towards the end of 2016. In terms of good governance principles, the foundation is a trust with independent trustees. For more information refer to page 67
  • A group CSI steering committee has been constituted and met in July 2016, fulfilling a management oversight role for sustainable socio-economic development in the company. Reports and minutes from this steering committee now form part of the social and ethics committee reports
  • Reviewed the company’s issues management approach
  • Reviewed progress against management plans for stakeholder relationships and stakeholder mapping
  • Reviewed the company’s ethics policies and processes, including those for anti-bribery and corruption
  • Reviewed and considered consumer care line reports. After a thorough review of this process, recommended changes are being implemented
  • Agreed the following in terms of human resources and labour-related matters:
    - The social impact of wage negotiations and fatalities are considered with respect to the well-being of employees and their families
    - HIV statistics are explored in terms of employee wellness and the progress of HIV programmes. The aim is to improve internal communication and reporting on progress
  • Going forward, the committee will consider certain matters as agenda items in more detail:
    - Unfair or inappropriate discrimination
    - Fair labour practices
    - Emolument attachment orders (garnishee orders).

Tiger Brands is committed to ensuring that its principles on ethics are implemented across the company. The committee will continue to monitor processes and policies to ensure compliance.

The committee is satisfied it has considered and discharged its responsibilities for the financial year in line with its terms of reference, King III and the Companies Act.

On behalf of the committee

Maya Makanjee
Chairman

22 November 2016