Chief financial officer's review

“Tiger Brands’ full year results have been impacted by the unbundling of the company’s interest in Oceana, the challenging operating environment, and a slower than anticipated recovery in the Value Added Meat Products (VAMP) business.”
Noel Doyle  Chief financial officer


SALIENT FEATURES*

Revenue

R29,2bn   3%

(excluding VAMP†, R28,6 bn 5%)

Operating income**

R2,6bn   20%

(excluding VAMP†, 11% R3,2 billion)

Group operating margin**

9,0%   260 bps

(2018: 11,6%)

HEPS

1 349 cps   17%

(2018: 1 633 cps)

EPS

2 364 cps   55%

(2018: 1 530 cps)

Total dividend***

1 061 cps   2%

(2018: 1 080 cps)

Unbundling of investment in

Oceana  

concluded

Deli Foods  

discontinued


* From continuing operations.
** Before impairments and abnormal items.
*** Includes special dividend of 306 cents per share declared on 22 May 2019.
† Refer to Annexure A of the audited group results and dividend declaration for the year ended 30 September 2019 available on the company’s website.

OVERVIEW

Tiger Brands’ results for the year ended 30 September 2019 reflect the difficult trading conditions, characterised by an increasingly challenging consumer environment and input costs rising ahead of price inflation. The overall result was significantly impacted by ongoing margin compression across the Grains portfolio, tough trading conditions in the group’s primary export markets and the slower than anticipated recovery of the VAMP business. The unbundling of the company’s investment in Oceana also had a significant impact on year-on-year comparisons. Details of the impact of VAMP and the unbundling of Oceana on key financial metrics are detailed below and overleaf.

Shareholders are referred to the SENS announcement issued by the company on 8 November 2019 regarding the cessation of operations at Deli Foods in Nigeria. The business has been treated as a discontinued operation in these results, with the comparative information restated accordingly.

Despite the challenging backdrop, total revenue from continuing operations increased by 3%, driven by price inflation of 5% and partially offset by an overall volume decline of 2%. Lower volumes, coupled with the inability to fully recover input costs, placed gross margins under pressure, resulting in group operating income before impairments and abnormal items (operating income) declining by 20% to R2,6 billion (2018: R3,3 billion).

Excluding VAMP*, operating income before impairments and abnormal items decreased by 11% to R3,2 billion compared to the reported decline of 20% to R2,6 billion.

The impairment charge was driven by a R96 million write-down in respect of VAMP’s property, plant and equipment and a R212 million goodwill impairment related to Davita, reflecting the challenging outlook in export markets. Abnormal income of R2,0 billion reported in the current period (2018: R422 million loss) largely comprises gains linked to the unbundling of Tiger Brands' stake in Oceana and related share disposals.

Income from associates decreased by 49% to R371 million (2018: R731 million). As previously reported, the company ceased to equity account the earnings of Oceana with effect from 1 December 2018, following the decision in November 2018 to unbundle the company’s investment in Oceana. The total income from associates is therefore not comparable with that of the prior year. All associates, including National Foods Zimbabwe (which has been accounted for in line with IAS 29 Financial Reporting in Hyperinflationary Economies), reported an increase in earnings.

Net financing costs of R11 million (2018: R42 million) benefited from lower average debt levels over the past year. In addition, a net foreign exchange gain of R10 million was realised compared to a gain of R21 million in the prior year.

The effective tax rate before abnormal items, impairments and income from associates has increased marginally in comparison with the prior year. The prior year’s effective tax rate has been restated to account for the discontinuation of Deli Foods in the current year.

Headline earnings per share (HEPS) from continuing operations declined by 17% to 1 349 cents (2018: 1 633 cents). Earnings per share (EPS) from continuing operations, on the other hand, increased by 55% to 2 364 cents (2018: 1 530 cents) principally due to a capital surplus amounting to R2 billion, arising from capital profits realised and a fair value gain relating to the unbundling of the company’s interest in Oceana. This capital surplus had no impact on headline earnings per share as it is excluded for headline earnings purposes.

After adjusting for the impact of VAMP*, the unbundling of Tiger Brands’ investment in Oceana, as well as the capital profit arising from the sale of Oceana shares, attributable earnings per share from continuing operations declined by 11% compared to the reported increase of 55%.

At a headline earnings level, after adjusting for VAMP and Oceana, headline earnings per share from continuing operations reflect a decline of 8% compared to the reported decline of 17%.

* Refer to Annexure A of the audited group results and dividend declaration for the year ended 30 September 2019 available on the company’s website.

The reconciling items between reported items and adjusted items are set out in the table below and overleaf.

Table 1: Adjusted headline earnings from continuing operations
   2019    2018         
   R’million  HEPS 
(cents)
  R’million  HEPS 
(cents)
% change 
cps 
  
Headline earnings as reported (continuing operations)1  2 234  1 349    2 689  1 633  (17%)   
Oceana equity-accounted earnings1  (31) (18)   (416) (252)      
Adjusted headline earnings – excluding Oceana2  2 203  1 331    2 273  1 381  (4%)   
VAMP – after-tax trading loss1  394  238    181  110       
VAMP – abnormal items after tax3  (54) (33)   303  184       
Adjusted headline earnings (excluding VAMP and Oceana)4  2 543  1 536    2 757  1 675  (8%)   
1 This has been extracted from Tiger Brands’ audited financial statements for the years ended 30 September 2019 and 30 September 2018.
2 Adjusted headline earnings after adjusting for all Oceana-related transactions for the year.
3 The effects of the VAMP losses have been removed as this had a significant year-on-year impact on normal operations. This has been extracted from note 3 – Impairments and note 4 – Abnormal items in the audited group results and dividend declaration for the year ended 30 September 2019 available on the company’s website.
4 Adjusted headline earnings after adjusting for all Oceana and VAMP-related transactions for the year.

HEPS from total operations decreased by 17% to 1 322 cents (2018: 1 589 cents), while EPS from total operations increased by 60% to 2 333 cents (2018: 1 458 cents).

BASIS OF PREPARATION

Non-IFRS measures, such as adjusted revenue from continuing operations, and adjusted operating income from continuing operations before impairments and abnormal items as well as adjusted earnings from continuing operations, are considered to be pro forma financial information as per the JSE Listings Requirements. The pro forma financial information is the responsibility of the group’s board of directors and is presented for illustrative purposes only. Due to its nature the pro forma financial information may not fairly present the company’s results of operations.

The pro forma financial information is based on the condensed consolidated income statement for the year ended 30 September 2019. The pro forma financial information has been prepared to illustrate the impact of the company’s unbundling of Oceana as well as VAMP’s performance on the condensed consolidated income statement for the year ended 30 September 2019.

The pro forma financial information is presented in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements. The JSE Listings Requirements require that pro forma financial information be compiled in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements, the SAICA Guide on Pro forma Financial Information and any relevant guidance issued by the IRBA.

Ernst & Young Inc.’s independent reporting accountants’ assurance report on the pro forma financial information for the year ended 30 September 2019 as presented in Annexure A of the audited group results and dividend declaration for 2019, is available for inspection at the company’s registered office. The independent reporting accountants’ assurance report on the pro forma financial information for the year ended 30 September 2019 does not necessarily report on all the information contained in Annexure A of the audited group results and dividend declaration for 2019. Shareholders are therefore advised that in order to obtain a full understanding of the nature of the independent reporting accountants’ engagement, they should obtain a copy of the independent reporting accountants’ assurance report together with the accompanying pro forma financial information for the year ended 30 September 2019 from the issuer’s registered office.

Table 2: Adjusted revenue from continuing operations
  2019 
R’million 
  2018 
R’million 
% change  
Revenue1 29 233    28 365  3%  
VAMP revenue for the period1 (654)   (1 066)    
Revenue excluding VAMP2 28 579    27 299  5%  
1 This has been extracted from Tiger Brands’ audited financial statements for the years ended 30 September 2019 and 30 September 2018.
2 Revenue from continuing operations excluding VAMP, the performance of which distorts the group’s performance as this had a significant year-on-year impact on normal operations.
Table 3: Adjusted operating income from continuing operations before impairments and abnormal items
   2019
R’million 
   2018
R’million 
% change    
Operating income before impairments and abnormal items1  2 623     3 289  (20%)   
VAMP losses1  547     252       
Adjusted operating income before impairments and abnormal items2  3 170     3 541  (11%)   
1 This has been extracted from Tiger Brands’ audited financial statements for the years ended 30 September 2019 and 30 September 2018.
2 Total adjusted operating income after adjusting for the VAMP operating losses which had a significant year-on-year impact on normal operations.
Table 4: Adjusted earnings from continuing operations
   2019       2018         
   R’million  EPS 
(cents)
   R’million  EPS 
(cents)
% change 
cps 
  
Earnings as reported (continuing operations)1  3 916  2 364     2 519  1 530  55%    
Oceana equity-accounted earnings1  (31)  (18)     (420)  (255)      
Oceana – profit on sale of associate investment2  (340)  (205)     –  –      
Oceana – realised fair value gain on unbundling2  (1 630)  (984)     –  –      
Adjusted earnings – excluding Oceana3  1 915  1 157     2 099  1 275  (9%)    
VAMP – after-tax trading loss1  394  238     181  110      
VAMP – impairments and abnormal items after tax2  21  13     328  199      
Adjusted earnings (excluding VAMP and Oceana)4  2 330  1 408     2 608  1 584  (11%)    
1 This has been extracted from Tiger Brands’ audited financial statements for the years ended 30 September 2019 and 30 September 2018.
2 The effects of the Oceana unbundling as well as the VAMP losses have been removed as these had a significant year-on-year impact on normal operations. Items have been extracted from note 3 – Impairments and note 6 – Abnormal Items in the audited group results and dividend declaration for the year ended 30 September 2019 available on the company’s website.
3 Adjusted earnings after adjusting for transactions related to the unbundling of the company’s interest in Oceana for the year.
4 Adjusted earnings after adjusting for transactions related to the unbundling of the company’s interest in Oceana and VAMP-related transactions for the year.

SEGMENTAL OPERATING PERFORMANCE

Domestic revenue increased by 5% to R26 billion in line with price inflation of 5%, with overall volume growth unchanged. Particularly strong performances were delivered by Snacks and Treats, Beverages, Home, Personal Care and Baby, offset by disappointing results in Grains and VAMP. Industrial action affecting Groceries in the first half and Bakeries in the second half, as well as load shedding during the year, had an adverse impact on both revenue and costs. These contributed to operating income from domestic operations decreasing by 19% to R2,5 billion (2018: R3,1 billion). Excluding VAMP, operating income from domestic operations, decreased by 9% to R3,0 billion (2018: R3,3 billion).

Total revenue for the Exports and International businesses declined by 11% to R3,2 billion, while operating income reduced by 34% to R212 million. A poor operating performance from Exports was partially offset by a significant recovery in the Deciduous Fruit business.

Further details of the performance of our operations are provided in our Operational Review.

CASH FLOW AND CAPITAL EXPENDITURE

Cash generated from operations increased by 6% to R3,5 billion. This improvement was largely the result of a reduction in working capital requirements of R91 million compared to an increased investment in working capital of R573 million in the prior year. The level of capital expenditure for the year accelerated to R1,1 billion (2018: R720 million) with investments across the group’s portfolio including various projects to deliver efficiency improvements and increase capacity. The group ended the year in a net cash position of R1,2 billion compared with a net cash position of R669 million in the previous year.

FINAL DIVIDEND

A gross final cash dividend of 434 cents per share has been declared for the year ended 30 September 2019. This, together with the interim ordinary dividend of 321 cents per share, brings the total ordinary dividend for the year to 755 cents, in line with Tiger Brands’ dividend policy of 1,75x cover based on headline earnings per share.

In addition, a special dividend of 306 cents per share was declared for the six months to 31 March 2019 as a result of the once-off proceeds received from the disposal of Oceana shares to Brimstone.

The special dividend, together with the total ordinary dividend for the year, brings the total distribution for the year to 1 061 cents per share (2018: 1 080 cents).

Shareholders are referred to the dividend announcement for further details.

OUTLOOK

Significant progress has been made in terms of optimising the portfolio, with firm decisions having been made in respect of VAMP and Deli Foods. With respect to the potential disposal of VAMP, the formal due diligence process is under way and further updates will be given as key milestones are reached. The ongoing work to optimise Tiger Brands’ portfolio will ensure that the group is appropriately positioned for growth.

It is expected that the significant macro-economic challenges facing the country are likely to persist for the foreseeable future. In the context of structural unemployment, ongoing challenges relating to state-owned enterprises and increased competitive pressure, the operating environment is likely to remain subdued. To this end, we will prioritise investment in the group’s key brands while delivering product innovations to meet changing consumer needs. In addition, Tiger Brands will leverage the strength of its brands by evaluating opportunities to stretch its brands within and across existing and new product categories.

In terms of Tiger Brands’ Africa growth strategy, the company is looking to deliver organic growth by driving category growth through targeted brand investments, developing superior routes to market and investing in enabling capabilities.

To protect margins in a constrained consumer environment, the company has placed heightened focus on driving productivity and securing cost efficiencies across the value chain.

APPRECIATION

Thank you to our local and international shareholders for your continued investment in the company and to the broader investment community for their interest and engagement. I also thank my colleagues in the finance department who constantly strive towards best practice standards and disclosure and extend my gratitude to the audit committee for their guidance throughout the year.

Noel Doyle

Chief financial officer

21 November 2019