Annexures

Annexures D

Share-based payment plans

The information noted below summarises all key assumptions, valuation inputs and key disclosures relating to the Tiger Brands share-based payment plans.

1
General Employee Share Option Plan
 

Certain senior employees are entitled to receive options based on merit. Options are issued annually by the board of directors of the company.

Between January 2006 and March 2013 a cash-settled option scheme was applied by the company, which replaced the previous equity-settled share option scheme. During March 2013, a hybrid scheme was introduced where executives and managers of the company and its subsidiaries are offered a weighted combination of:

  • Allocations of share appreciation rights
  • Conditional awards of full-value performance shares (last allocation to employees – 24 May 2016)
  • Grants of full-value restricted shares (bonus-matching and deferral element).

This hybrid scheme is regarded as an equity-settled share option scheme.

Share appreciation rights

The following table illustrates the number and weighted average exercise prices (WAEPs) of, and movements in, share appreciation rights during the year:

  2018   2017  
  Number    WAEP    Number    WAEP   
Outstanding at beginning of the year  1 441 342     336,2     1 064 783     301,4    
Granted during the year  594 390     414,5     553 092     396,2    
Forfeited during the year  (405 446)    360,8     (140 482)    329,3    
Exercised during the year  (46 517)    259,6     (36 051)    255,2    
Outstanding at end of the year  1 583 769     363,7     1 441 342     336,2    
Exercisable at end of the year  160 472     270,0     82 536     257,0    
Weighted average remaining contractual life (years)       3,8 years           4,0 years    
Weighted average fair value of options granted (per option)       127,7           108,1    
Range of exercise prices outstanding at end of the year (per option)       R254,5 – R414,5           R254,5 – R403,6    

Options were valued using a modified Black-Schöles model taking into account the dividend cover, expected exercise pattern and volatility of the Tiger Brands share price. Subject to certain performance conditions, one-third of the equity-settled share options vest on each of the third, fourth and fifth anniversary dates from the date of the original grant date. All the equitysettled options mature six years after the grant date.

The following inputs were used:

Date of grant Strike price
of option
(Rand)
Expiry date   Market price
of the
underlying
stock at
grant date
(Rand)
  Expected
volatility of
the stock over
the remaining
life of the
option (%)
  Expected
dividend
cover
(times)
 
13/02/2014 254,5 12/02/2020   250,0   21,5   3,0  
04/02/2015 385,3 04/02/2020   394,9   21,3   2,9  
09/02/2016 291,7 09/02/2021   302,9   25,5   3,0  
31/03/2016 322,4 31/03/2021   325,2   25,7   3,0  
24/05/2016 341,7 24/05/2021   337,0   25,7   2,9  
07/12/2016 396,0 07/12/2021   386,8   25,8   2,9  
05/09/2017 403,6 05/09/2022   380,0   24,9   2,8  
11/12/2017 414,5 11/12/2023   425,0   24,7   2,8  

Volatilities are based on the historical volatility of the Tiger Brands share price matching the remaining life of each option.

Performance shares

The following table illustrates the number of, and movements in, performance shares during the year:

  2018 
Number 
  2017 
Number 
 
Outstanding at beginning of the year  94 850     156 850   
Granted during the year  –     –   
Forfeited during the year  (17 317)    (12 948)  
Exercised during the year  (15 531)    (49 052)  
Outstanding at end of the year  62 002     94 850   
Exercisable at end of the year  21 221     –   
Weighted average remaining contractual life (years) 0,3 years     1,3 years   

Options were valued using the Monte Carlo simulation approach to estimate the price of the options that are subject to TSR market performance conditions using 50 000 simulations taking into account the dividend cover, expected exercise pattern and volatility of the Tiger Brands share price.

The following inputs were used:

Date of grant Expiry date   Market price
of the
underlying
stock at
grant date
(Rand)
  Expected
volatility of
the stock over
the remaining
life of the
option (%)
  Expected
dividend
cover
(times)
 
28/02/2014 27/02/2017   244,4   22,4   3,0  
04/02/2015 04/02/2018   394,9   23,6   2,9  
09/02/2016 04/02/2019   302,9   27,5   3,0  
24/05/2016 24/05/2019   337,0   27,0   2,9  

Volatilities are based on the historical volatility of the Tiger Brands share price matching the remaining life of each option.

Restricted shares

The following table illustrates the number of, and movements in, restricted shares during the year:

  2018 
Number 
  2017 
Number 
 
Outstanding at beginning of the year  205 820     192 378   
Granted during the year  139 070     57 010   
Forfeited during the year  (35 921)    (17 654)  
Exercised during the year  (66 045)    (25 914)  
Outstanding at end of the year  242 924     205 820   
Exercisable at end of the year  16 952     11 200   
Weighted average remaining contractual life (years) 1,4 years     1,7 years   
Weighted average fair value of options granted (per option) 391,4     354,8   

Options were valued using a modified Black-Schöles model taking into account the dividend cover, expected exercise pattern and volatility of the Tiger Brands share price.

The following inputs were used:

Date of grant Expiry date   Market price
of the
underlying
stock at
grant date
(Rand)
  Expected
volatility of
the stock over
the remaining
life of the
option (%)
  Expected
dividend
cover
(times)
 
28/02/2014 27/02/2017   244,4   22,4   3,0  
04/02/2015 04/02/2018   394,9   23,6   2,9  
03/12/2015 03/12/2018   320,0   26,3   3,0  
09/02/2016 09/02/2019   302,9   27,5   3,0  
31/03/2016 31/03/2019   325,2   27,4   3,0  
07/12/2016 07/12/2019   386,8   26,9   2,9  
31/03/2017 31/03/2020   325,2   27,4   3,0  
11/12/2017 07/12/2020   425,0   25,4   2,8  

Volatilities are based on the historical volatility of the Tiger Brands share price matching the remaining life of each option.

Cash-settled

The following table illustrates the number and weighted average exercise prices (WAEPs) of, and movements in, cash-settled options during the year:

  2018   2017  
  Number    WAEP    Number    WAEP   
Outstanding at beginning of the year  124 203    274,6    271 076    249,5   
Granted during the year  –    –    –    –   
Forfeited during the year  (21 492)   291,6    (6 253)   263,8   
Exercised during the year  (53 396)   258,7     (140 620)   227,2   
Outstanding at end of the year  49 315    282,9    124 203    274,6   
Exercisable at end of the year  49 315    282,9    82 301    265,7   
Weighted average remaining contractual life (years)      –         0,9 years    
Range of exercise prices outstanding at end of the year (per option)      R252,0 – R299,8         R252,0 – R299,8   
Weighted average share price at the date of exercise (per option)      426,6          R403,0   

Cash options were valued using a modified Black-Schöles model taking into account the dividend cover, expected exercise pattern and volatility of the Tiger Brands share price. Subject to certain performance conditions, one-third of the cash-settled share options vest on each of the third, fourth and fifth anniversary dates from the date of the original grant date. All the cash-settled options mature six years after the grant date.

The following inputs were used:

Date of grant Strike price
of option
(Rand)
Expiry date   Market price
of the
underlying
stock at
grant date
(Rand
  Expected
volatility of
the stock over
the remaining
life of the
option (%)
  Expected
dividend
cover
(times)
 
03/02/2012 253,2 02/02/2018   255,0   31,3   2,9  
02/07/2012 252,0 01/07/2018   247,0   31,3   2,9  
01/10/2012 265,4 30/09/2018   272,4   31,3   2,9  
13/02/2013 299,8 12/02/2019   289,5   30,4   2,9  

The average volatility was 30,5% (2017: 20,33%) and the risk-free rate was 7,20% (2017: 7,09%) during the year.

The carrying amount of the liability relating to the cash-settled options at 30 September 2018 is R0,3 million (2017: R13,2 million) – refer to note 27. Cash-settled options exercised during the year amounted to R9,1 million (2017: R26,4 million).

Volatilities are based on the historical volatility of the Tiger Brands share price matching the remaining life of each option.

2
Black Managers Participation Right Scheme (equity-settled)
 

In terms of the BEE transaction implemented on 17 October 2005, 4 381 831 Tiger Brands shares were acquired by the Tiger Brands Black Managers Trust.

The allocation of vested rights entitles beneficiaries to receive Tiger Brands shares (after making capital contributions to the Black Managers Trust) at any time after the lock-in period. In respect of options allocated on or before 31 July 2010, the lock-in period ends on 31 December 2014. In respect of allocations made after 31 July 2010, the lock-in date will be the latter of 31 December 2014 or, in respect of one-third of the allocations, three years after the allocation, the next third, four years and the last third, five years after the allocation. These vested rights are non-transferable.

After the lock-in date, the beneficiaries may exercise their vested rights, in which event the beneficiary may:

  • Instruct trustees to sell all of their shares and distribute the proceeds to them, net of the funds required to pay the capital contributions, taxation (including employees’ tax), costs and expenses
  • Instruct the trustees to sell sufficient shares to fund the capital contributions, pay the taxation (including employees’ tax), costs and expenses, and distribute to them the remaining shares to which they are entitled
  • Fund the capital contributions, taxation (including employees’ tax) costs and expenses themselves and receive the shares to which they are entitled.

The expense recognised for employee services received during the year to 30 September 2018 is R25,3 million (2017: R15,9 million).

The following table illustrates the number of, and movements in, share participation rights during the year:

  2018 
Number 
  2017 
Number 
 
Outstanding at beginning of the year  1 035 365     1 002 284    
Granted during the year  35 000     303 000    
Forfeited during the year  (101 435)    (52 889)   
Shares sold  (129 803)    (217 030)   
Outstanding at end of the year  839 127     1 035 365    
Exercisable at end of the year  466 017     513 494    
Weighted average remaining contractual life (years) 7,9 years     10,0 years    
Weighted average fair value of options granted during the year (per option) R351,1     R334,5    
Notional average exercise price (per option) R415,9     R404,9    

Participation rights were valued using the Monte-Carlo simulation approach to estimate the average, optimal pay-off of the participation rights using 10 000 permutations. The pay-off of each random path was based on: the projected Tiger Brands share price, outstanding debt projections and optimal early-exercise conditions.

Volatility is measured as the annualised standard deviation of the daily price changes in the underlying share under the assumption that the share price is log-normally distributed. Historical daily share price data was used to estimate the expected volatility.

The following inputs were used:

Date of grant Initial strike
price of
participation
rights
(Rand)
Expiry date   Market price
of the
underlying
stock at
grant date
(Rand)
  Expected
volatility
of the stock
over the
remaining
life of the
participation
right
(%)
  Expected
dividend
yield of the
stock over
the remaining
life of the
participation
right (%)
 
31/01/2014 85,8 30/09/2027   266,0   25,3   3,8  
31/07/2014 85,9 30/09/2027   308,8   25,3   3,8  
31/01/2015 81,9 30/09/2027   394,2   25,3   3,8  
31/07/2015 82,5 30/09/2027   284,9   25,3   3,8  
31/01/2016 79,0 30/09/2027   291,0   25,3   3,8  
31/07/2017 74,5 31/07/2023   399,5   24,1   3,8  
31/01/2018 70,6 31/01/2024   461,0   24,6   2,9  
31/07/2018 69,6 31/07/2024   350,0   26,0   3,2  

The risk-free interest rate was obtained from constructed ZAR swap curves on the valuation dates using key inputs, being South African money market rates and swap rates as published by Bloomberg.

3
Black Managers Trust II and Brimstone participation right schemes (equity-settled)
 

Brimstone

Brimstone held 1 813 613 Tiger Brands shares via Brim Tiger SPV Proprietary Limited (Brimstone SPV). Brimstone and the Brimstone SPV were prohibited in selling or encumbering such shares until 31 December 2017 (the “end date”). The IFRS 2 charge of R61,9 million relating to Brimstone has been expensed upfront.

Tiger Brands repurchased 861 257 shares from Brimstone SPV at a subscription price of R7,40 and the number of shares were calculated in terms of a repurchase formula, whose inputs were:

  • The total discounted value of the shares (being an amount equal to R148,07 per share) less the initial equity contribution by Brimstone, increased over the transaction term by a hurdle rate (being 85% of the prevailing prime rate)
  • An amount equal to 85% of the distributions declared by Tiger Brands but not received by Brimstone SPV as a result of the condition attaching to the issue of the shares increased over the transaction term by the hurdle rate
  • The market value of a Tiger Brands ordinary share at the end date; and
  • The subscription price of R7,40 per share.

The remaining 952 356 Tiger Brands shares were retained by Brimstone SPV.

Black Managers Trust II

Over the period of the Tiger Brands Black Managers Trust No II (BMT) 2 814 149 Tiger Brands shares were allocated to qualifying black managers. The lock-in period for the scheme expired on 31 December 2017. Immediately following this date, Tiger Brands exercised its rights in terms of a repurchase option and repurchased 1 389 685 shares from the BMT II at a subscription price of 10 cents per share.

The remaining shares, 1 424 464, were distributed to the participating black managers, with 130 361 shares subject to a further retention period of three years, which will expire on 30 September 2020.

The number of shares repurchased by Tiger Brands were calculated in terms of a repurchase formula, the inputs of which are similar to those as disclosed under the “Brimstone” heading above, other than for the fact that 90% of any distributions declared by Tiger Brands are not received by the Black Managers Trust II (as opposed to 85% in the case of Brimstone SPV) and the subscription price is 10 cents per share (as opposed to R7,40 in the case of the Brimstone SPV).

The expense recognised for employee services received during the year to 30 September 2018 is R21,1 million (2017: R19,3 million).

The following table illustrates the number of, and movements in, share participation rights during the year:

  2018 
Number 
  2017 
Number 
 
Outstanding at beginning of the year  2 814 792     2 678 372    
Granted during the year  –     259 620    
Forfeited during the year  (643)    (123 200)   
Shares sold/distributed during the year  (2 814 149)    –    
Outstanding at end of the year  –     2 814 792    
Exercisable at end of the year  –     –    
Weighted average remaining contractual life (years) –     1,3 years    
Weighted average fair value of options granted during the year (per option) –     R193,1    
Notional average exercise price (per option) –     R202,9