Remuneration report

This remuneration report primarily covers the remuneration of the company’s executive and non-executive directors, as well as that of senior management (including prescribed officers and members of the executive committee).

The remuneration policy, approved by the shareholders by way of a non-binding advisory vote, at the AGM held on 11 February 2014, is set out below. The remuneration policy is regularly reviewed by the remuneration committee to ensure that it reflects best practice and remains competitive and relevant to Tiger Brands’ employee value proposition.

Remuneration policy

Objective

The Tiger Brands remuneration policy aims to ensure that the group attracts and retains key and critical talent required to deliver the group’s business goals and results.

The policy, in conjunction with the remuneration philosophy and strategy, is predicated on the following key principles:

Remuneration should support the vision to be the most admired, branded FMCG company in selected emerging markets by attracting and retaining the right talent.
Remuneration should have a direct correlation with the growth plans and financial performance of the businesses and the group.
Remuneration should be reviewed and benchmarked annually through professional in-country service providers to ensure the group remains competitive in the diverse markets in which it operates, never applying percentiles rigidly but taking into account industry type, skills scarcity, performance and legislative structures and requirements.
Remuneration must support the group’s strategy, and be consistent with the organisation’s culture of fairness and equity.
Remuneration should motivate, drive deeper engagement and allow for differentiation in rewarding high performers.
Individual contribution based on the role and responsibilities should have a direct bearing on the levels of remuneration.
Variable remuneration (short and long-term incentives) practices should be tested periodically through external service providers to ensure these practices support the group’s objective of reward for achievement of short-term and long-term growth, as well as the retention of talent. The remuneration committee actively participates in the entire process.

Remuneration mix, recognition and reward

The Tiger Brands group remuneration and reward system comprises the following elements:

Definitions of terms used in this policy

Total remuneration package (excluding bargaining unit employees): comprises base pay and benefits and is differentiated based on performance and the size and complexity of the business.
Short-term incentives (for employees in middle management and above): annual short-term cash incentive that is based on the attainment of financial and strategic objectives. Primarily this scheme is intended to improve financial performance and focus the attention of participants on key strategic objectives.
Long-term incentive (for employees in senior management and above): the medium to long-term investment by the group, through its various share incentive schemes, in its key talent to ensure sustained long-term growth and health of the group.
The group also invests in the development of employees to ensure sustainable growth and excellent performance.

Total remuneration package (guaranteed)

In determining the appropriate level of total remuneration package, the following is taken into consideration:

A role profile is determined based on competencies, outputs and behaviours required for the job.
The role profile fit within the organisational structure is determined and the appropriate job grade assigned.
Comparisons are made annually with external and internal benchmarks to ensure equity, fairness and defensibility.
Appropriate market percentiles are applied based on skills, experience, affordability and market competitiveness.
For existing employees, market percentiles are based on performance ratings, time in the role, whether development is still required to fulfil the role requirements, and value-add to the business and organisation as a whole.
Scarce skills are determined annually and where scarcity is due to demand outstripping supply, a plan is put in place to derisk the business or organisation. Where scarcity is as a consequence of a unique combination of skills and experience an individual holds, deliberate efforts are made to build a talent pool around the scarce individual to derisk the business or organisation. Total remuneration package applied to this category of people is targeted at the top end of the market range or alternatively a non-pensionable temporary adjustment is considered until such time as the market stabilises or the risk is mitigated.
The composition of the total remuneration package includes both compulsory (eg retirement) benefits and discretionary (eg medical aid) benefits. As the group has implemented a total remuneration package approach, employees are afforded a choice to join the Tiger Brands Medical Scheme should they value the quality of benefits offered.
Total remuneration packages are reviewed annually in October of each year. Interim reviews to total remuneration packages may be undertaken to retain talent, adjust to market, and upon promotion of employees.

Short-term incentive

The group’s short-term incentive scheme is designed to drive improvement of the group results on an annual basis. The scheme is governed by the scheme rules which are reviewed and approved by the group’s remuneration committee annually.

Eligibility for participation is based on the attainment of annual targets, both financial and strategic objectives.
Only qualifying employees who are rated full performer, strong performer or exceptional performer during the year under review participate in the short-term incentive scheme.
Need development performers and under-performers do not participate in the short-term incentive scheme.
Employees who have been found guilty of gross misconduct will not be allowed to participate in the incentive scheme.
No adjustments are made for extraneous factors; the short-term incentive is based on reported earnings.

Long-term incentive

The long-term incentive scheme is designed to retain employees in the medium to long term, to focus their attention on longer-term strategic imperatives and to ensure sustained future growth of the organisation. This scheme is governed by rules which are reviewed and updated by the remuneration committee as necessary for alignment with best practice.

The group’s executives and senior managers are eligible for participation in the group’s long-term incentive scheme.
Eligibility criteria, the quantum of allocations and grants, as well as the conditions governing each allocation and grant, are determined by the remuneration committee.
Allocations are made annually.
The board determines appropriate measures in dealing with allocations and grants made to employees who have subsequently been found guilty of gross misconduct.

Recognition and rewards

The group has in place mechanisms for recognising and rewarding its employees for excellence in various categories including high performance, living the values, continuous improvement, etc.

The group encourages participation in motivational programmes by individual businesses.
The businesses are encouraged to align their programmes to Tiger Stripes, the group’s values-based recognition programme.
Businesses should invest in the development of employees to ensure sustained performance and growth.
All people development initiatives should align to the business goals and be based on the personal development plans.

Governance

In all areas of remuneration, the remuneration committee takes an active role in reviewing the remuneration philosophy, policy, strategy and practices for alignment to best practice and strategic imperatives of the group. The desired outcome of the policy is to facilitate the attraction and retention of the right talent for the group.

Variation

The above policy may be varied at the discretion of the executive committee (for guaranteed remuneration) or the remuneration committee (for the incentive schemes) at any time. This may include the addition or deletion of benefits, as the case may be. The policy will apply to all employees regardless of the policy that applied at the time of the appointment of such employees.

The policy is to be read in conjunction with the company’s letter of appointment, disciplinary code, Code of Ethics, applicable employment legislation, as well as the company’s short-term and long-term incentive scheme rules.

Executive remuneration

The total remuneration packages of the executive directors and senior management are subject to annual review and independently benchmarked against external market data taking into account the size of the company, its market sector and business complexity. Individual performance, as reflected by formal performance ratings, value-add to the business and organisation as a whole, and overall responsibility is also taken into consideration. For consistently high performers, it is the group’s intention to set guaranteed (non-variable) pay at above-median levels of remuneration as reflected by an appropriate external executive remuneration survey.

Details of remuneration payable to executive directors, prescribed officers and members of the executive committee in respect of the 2013 and 2014 financial years, are set out in note 4.2 of the notes to the annual financial statements.

Outside of the total remuneration package structure, executive directors and senior management participate in a short-term incentive bonus plan and in the Tiger Brands 2013 Share Plan (and historically the Tiger Brands (1985) Share Option Scheme and the Tiger Brands Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme). One executive director and four members of the Tiger Brands executive committee are also participants in either one or both of the company’s black manager empowerment schemes.

Incentive bonus plan

The executive directors and senior management participate in an annual incentive bonus plan, which is based on the achievement of short-term performance targets. These targets comprise a financial component, as well as a number of strategic components. In 2014, the short-term incentive scheme in respect of members of the Tiger Brands executive committee (including the Chief Executive Officer) carried an 80% weighting in respect of the financial component and a 20% weighting for the strategic component.

The financial performance component is based on growth in profits, as measured by headline earnings per share (HEPS), and the return on net assets employed, with the greater emphasis on growth in HEPS. Measures and targets are set and reviewed annually by the remuneration committee.

In 2014, the strategic element of the bonus consisted of a number of components, focusing on the following areas (weightings denoted in brackets):

Significant improvement in Tiger Brands Nigeria - measured through the achievement of specific financial targets that have been set (5% weighting).
Meaningful increase in the group’s innovation rate - a minimum increase of one percentage point in the group’s innovation rate, measured as a percentage of total group turnover (5% weighting).
Demonstrable progress in regaining Tiger Brands’ market shares - measured through the achievement of a specified total volume growth target for the categories in which Tiger Brands participates (5% weighting).
Achievement of net savings of R200 million in respect of specific group cost-saving initiatives - in the areas of financial shared services, information technology, procurement and manufacturing (5% weighting).

Performance against individual targets and objectives is also taken into account in the final bonus determination. For an on-target performance, participants are able to earn an annual incentive equal to 50% of total remuneration package. All participants in this scheme are able to earn an annual short-term incentive of up to 150% of total remuneration package, increasing progressively from 100% to 150% for a performance above the top target. The maximum short-term incentive is paid only when the company achieves stretch business performance targets and all the strategic targets are achieved.

Incentive bonuses payable to executive directors in respect of 2014 are set out in the table of directors’ emoluments included under note 4.2 of the notes to the annual financial statements. In addition, incentive bonuses payable to prescribed officers are reflected in a separate table below directors’ emoluments. Incentive bonuses payable to members of the executive committee, excluding executive directors and prescribed officers, are disclosed in aggregate under note 4.2 of the notes to the annual financial statements.

During September 2014, the remuneration committee appointed PricewaterhouseCoopers to conduct a holistic review of the company’s short-term incentive scheme. The objective of the review was to ensure that the company’s short-term incentive scheme was in line with best practice and that the construction of the scheme had the correct balance between personal performance and business performance.

Following the review, it has been decided that, in line with local and global best practice, the structure of the short-term incentive plan for executive directors and senior managers will now be calculated on a multiplier basis, with:

Short-term incentive = total remuneration package (TRP) x on-target % x business multiplier x personal multiplier

The business multiplier will range from 0% for unacceptable business performance, to 100% for meeting suitably challenging performance targets to a maximum of 150% for meeting stretch targets. The personal multiplier, which will also range from 0% to 150%, will reflect the performance of each individual based on their own performance against a set of measures and targets aligned with their portfolio and responsibilities. The business multiplier will have a weighting of 70% based on HEPS performance, and 30% based on strategic measures. The strategic measures for 2015 will focus on the further recovery of Tiger Brands’ market shares, product innovation, new cost reduction initiatives, performance management, leadership development and the continued reduction in the losses at Tiger Brands Nigeria in line with the planned turnaround strategy.

The on-target levels will be unchanged for 2015 at 50% of TRP, with a maximum incentive of 112,5% of TRP in the case of meeting stretch business and personal performance levels.

Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme

The Tiger Brands Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme was adopted on 23 February 2006 to replace the Tiger Brands (1985) Share Option Scheme. The remaining outstanding options in the latter scheme have to be exercised by no later than 24 January 2015. In terms of the Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme, cash options have been granted to executive directors and senior managers on an annual basis from 2006 to the last allocation in February 2013. This final allocation in February 2013 was made as part of the transition to the newly approved Tiger Brands 2013 Share Plan.

The rules of the Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme are based on the 1985 Equity-settled Share Option Scheme. Apart from the fact that the options are “cash settled” rather than “equity settled”, the major difference between the two schemes is that the maturity period of the cash-settled options is six years as opposed to 10 years. The cash options awarded from 2006 to 2009 have already fully vested.

Subject to meeting certain minimum performance conditions in respect of 50% of the options granted, all options granted from 2009 to 2013 are exercisable in equal one-third tranches on each of the third, fourth and fifth anniversary dates of the date of the original grant. The performance vesting condition in respect of 50% of the options granted requires that the company’s HEPS increases by a minimum of 3% per annum above inflation, on a rolling cumulative basis, over the relevant three, four and five-year performance periods. If the minimum financial hurdle rate is not achieved, annual retesting of the performance condition is permitted up to the sixth anniversary of the date of original grant in respect of the options granted in 2009 and 2010. It is to be noted that all the cash-settled options granted in 2009 have fully vested as at 30 September 2014.

For phantom cash options issued from 2011 onwards, and in line with the principles of King III, annual retesting of the performance condition is not permitted. These options are subject to a sliding vesting scale (based on varying levels of real growth in HEPS) which is applied on the third, fourth and fifth anniversary dates of the original grant date of the options, in respect of each one-third tranche, respectively.

The grant price of the cash-settled options awarded in 2009 and 2010 is equal to the average closing market price of a Tiger Brands share on the JSE for the 30 trading days immediately prior to the grant date of the option. From 2011 onwards, the method of determination of the grant price was changed from the 30-day average closing share price prior to the date of the option grant to the 10-day volume weighted average price (VWAP) prior to the grant date. The use of a 10-day VWAP price smooths out any volatility in the share price in the period immediately leading up to the grant date. The cash settlement amount of the option is equal to the difference between the closing market price of a Tiger Brands share on the date on which the option is exercised and the grant price.

Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan

The Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan, which was implemented in February 2013, is in line with global best practice and emerging South African practice, as it gives recognition to the required attributes of shareholder alignment, retention of key talent and long-term sustained performance.

The purpose of the 2013 Share Plan is to attract, retain, motivate and reward those executives and managers who are able to influence the performance of Tiger Brands and its subsidiaries on a basis which aligns their interests with those of the company’s shareholders.

Under the 2013 Share Plan, executives and selected managers of the company and its subsidiaries will be offered, on an annual basis, a weighted combination of:

allocations of share appreciation rights;
conditional awards of full-value performance shares; and
grants of full-value restricted shares.

The correlation between share price and company financial performance is often beset by exogenous factors that can sometimes override executive performance. The 2013 Share Plan focuses executive attention and reward on performance by combining a growth-oriented element (share appreciation right) with two full-value elements, the one rewarding future company performance (performance share) and the other rewarding actual individual performance and retaining key talent (restricted share).

The share appreciation right element is similar in architecture to Tiger Brands’ 2006 Cash-settled Phantom Share Option Scheme. Under the latter scheme, annual allocations were made using a set multiple of guaranteed package to define a face value. The number of phantom share options was then derived by dividing the face value amount by the prevailing share (strike) price. The same methodology has been retained for allocations of share appreciation rights under the 2013 Share Plan, but with a reduced set multiple in order to accommodate the parallel offer of the two other elements, both forms of full-value shares.

When a participant exercises a phantom share option or share appreciation right, the value that accrues to him/her is the positive gain (appreciation) of the underlying share price above the strike price. Full-value shares differ in that there is no strike price; the full value of the share accrues to a participant on vesting. As such, full-value shares are less reliant on share price growth, and less sensitive to the volatility of share prices, the timing of offers and the external factors that can drive share prices.

Performance shares closely align the interests of shareholders and executives by rewarding superior shareholder and financial performance in the future. Performance shares will be awarded predominantly to senior executives who can influence and impact long-term strategic performance.

Restricted shares provide for share-based retention to those senior managers who through their performance on an annual basis, have demonstrated their value to the company. Restricted shares will be predominantly granted to high-performing senior managers to assist in their retention. The restricted share element of the plan will also offer the opportunity for executives to electively waive a portion (25%, 33% or 50%) of their annual cash incentive bonus, and to use the elective deferred portion to invest in Tiger Brands shares and have them matched by the company with additional shares.

Offers will be governed by Tiger Brands’ reward philosophy and strategy, in which a target reward is set for defined categories of executives and senior management. Target reward is defined as the present value of the future reward outcome of an allocation, given the targeted future performance of the company and of its share price.

The combined, weighted implementation of the above elements of the 2013 Share Plan will allow Tiger Brands to remain competitive in annual and share-based incentives, and will ensure that executives share a significant level of personal risk with the company’s shareholders.

Share appreciation rights element

Annual allocations of share appreciation rights will be made to executives and selected managers. They will be available to be settled in equal thirds on the third, fourth and fifth anniversaries of the date of allocation, but need not be exercised until the sixth anniversary, at which time they must be exercised or they will lapse.

On settlement, the value accruing to participants will be the appreciation of Tiger Brands’ share price. Settlement may be via cash (as is the case in the 2006 Phantom Cash Option Scheme) or in shares, which shares may be issued and allotted, or acquired and transferred to participants. It is the company’s intention that these be settled in shares.

These share appreciation rights will be subject to performance vesting criteria in terms of which the number of share appreciation rights vesting in relation to the full number allocated will be proportionately reduced if company financial performance targets are not met. The performance criteria in the following table have previously been adopted in respect of the 2006 Phantom Cash Option Scheme for the vesting of 50% of any allocation, and will now continue to be applied to 100% of any allocation of share appreciation rights.

Sliding scale for the application of performance vesting conditions based on a targeted increase of 3% per annum real growth rate in HEPS over three, four and five-year periods

Threshold levels for real HEPS growth % of allocation
to vest
 
>0% and <0,5% 5%  
≥0,5% and <1,0% 10%  
≥1,0% and <1,5% 16%  
≥1,5% and <2,0% 27%  
≥2,0% and <2,5% 44%  
≥2,5% and <3,0% 75%  
≥3,0% 100%  

The allocation of share appreciation rights will be at a reduced level in comparison to allocations previously made under the Phantom Cash Option Scheme, with the balance of the allocation comprising a weighted combination of the other two elements that are described in more detail below.

In February 2014, a special discretionary retention allocation of top-up share appreciation rights was made to qualifying 2013 Share Plan participants who either did not earn a short-term incentive bonus in 2013 or whose short-term incentive bonus was based on a performance below the on-target threshold. The purpose of this special allocation was to ensure the retention of key strategic employees of the group. This special retention allocation of share appreciation rights is subject to the same performance conditions and vesting periods to which the normal annual allocations of share appreciation rights are subject. A total number of 108 844 options, at a strike price of R254,45 per share, were allocated in terms hereof.

Performance share element

Annual conditional awards of performance shares will be made to executives and senior managers. Performance shares will vest on the third anniversary of their award, to the extent that the company has met specified performance criteria over the intervening period. Essentially the value per share that vests is the full value of the share (there is no strike price), but the number of shares that will vest will depend on the company’s performance over the intervening three-year period against set targets.

The board will determine the performance criteria for each award. In respect of the awards made in February 2013 and February 2014, it was agreed that vesting will be determined in terms of the company’s comparative total shareholder return (TSR) in relation to the constituent members of the FINDI 30 Index.

The vesting of the 2013 and 2014 performance shares will thus be based on the following relationships:

If Tiger Brands’ TSR over the three-year period places it in 15th position out of the 30 companies comprising the “index”, then the targeted number (one-third of the maximum number) of performance shares awarded will vest.
If Tiger Brands’ TSR over the three-year period places it in 7th position or better, then the maximum number (three times the targeted number) of performance shares awarded will vest.
If Tiger Brands’ TSR over the three-year period places it in 23rd position or worse, then all performance shares awarded will be forfeited.
If Tiger Brands’ performance over the three-year period lies between 7th position and 15th position on the one hand, or between 15th position and 23rd position on the other hand, then a pro-rated number of performance shares will vest.

No retesting against the performance criteria will be allowed. Any performance shares which do not vest at the end of the three-year period will be forfeited. It is envisaged that the awards of performance shares will feature at all executive and senior management levels, but feature more strongly the higher the participant’s grade within the organisation.

Restricted share element

On an annual basis, executives, senior managers and key talent will receive a grant of restricted shares. The value of restricted shares granted will be linked to the annual cash bonus scheme, in one of, or a combination of the following:

Bonus matching

Matching, according to a specified ratio, the actual annual cash incentive accruing to the executive. Standard matching ratios have been set for each grade, based on:
• the on-target bonus percentage for the grade; and
• the required balance within the offers of full-value shares between performance shares and restricted shares:
• Chief Executive Officer – 70%/30%,
• F Lower – 60%/40%, and
• E Upper and E Lower – 50%/50%.

Bonus deferral

An elective, prior year-end deferral of a portion (25%, 33% or 50%) of an individual’s actual bonus calculation and its immediate conversion into restricted shares, with matching by the company (according to a set ratio) with additional restricted shares.

As the individual is effectively opting to put an element of a cash bonus that would otherwise accrue to him/her at risk, the bonus deferral sub-element of the 2013 Share Plan may be referred to as a “co-investment plan”. All restricted shares will vest after three years and are not subject to any further performance conditions. The restricted share element provides for share-based retention to those executives who through their performance on an annual basis have demonstrated their value and commitment to the company.

Vesting of share options in the event of termination of employment – Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme

In the event that an individual’s employment is terminated, vesting of any outstanding (unvested) share options under the Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme is dependent upon the reasons for termination. The termination rules are in line with the recommendations contained in King III following certain changes which were made to the rules in late 2010.

A comparison of the old and new rules is set out in the table that follows. The new rules are applicable to phantom cash options awarded from 1 January 2011 onwards.

  Termination event Old rule (options awarded before 1 January 2011) New rule (options awarded from 1 January 2011)  
  Resignation Options not exercised on or before the last date of employment will lapse No change  
  Normal retirement There will be no early vesting. All options will be retained and will vest post-retirement subject to normal vesting criteria No change  
  Early retirement There will be no early vesting of options. For options granted prior to January 2009, all options will be retained. However, for options granted in 2009 and 2010, the number of options that will be retained will be pro-rated based on the period of service at the date of early retirement relative to the full vesting period of the unvested options. Retained options will vest post-retirement subject to the normal vesting criteria applicable to the respective years No change, but a sliding scale has replaced annual retesting  
  Retrenchment The number of options to be retained will be pro-rated based on the period of service at the date of retrenchment relative to the full vesting period of the unvested options. Such options will be allowed to vest early, and the performance conditions waived. Such retained options must be exercised within a period of six months after the date of retrenchment No change, other than that only 50% of the retained options must be exercised within the six-month period after the date of retrenchment. The remainder will continue to be subject to performance conditions (but a sliding scale has replaced annual re-testing)  
  Disposal of a subsidiary or business Performance conditions are waived and all unvested options are deemed to vest on the date of disposal. Such options must be exercised within a period of six months after the date of disposal The number of options to be retained will be pro-rated based on the period of service at the date of disposal relative to the full vesting period of the unvested options. A total of 50% of the retained options must be exercised within the six-month period after the date of disposal. The remainder will continue to be subject to performance conditions (with a sliding scale replacing annual re-testing)

 
  Death Performance conditions are waived and all unvested options are deemed to vest on the date of death. Such options must be exercised by the executor within a period of six months after date of death No change – although not in line with King III, a pragmatic approach has been taken in view of the small number of incidents  
  Dismissals Options not exercised on or before the last date of employment will lapse No change  

Vesting of share appreciation rights and full–value shares in the event of termination of employment - The Tiger Brands 2013 Share Plan

In the event that an individual’s employment is terminated, vesting of any outstanding (unvested) share options or full-value shares under the 2013 Share Plan is dependent upon the reasons for termination. The termination rules are in line with the recommendations contained in King III. The following is a summary of the principles to be applied in respect of units awarded under the 2013 Share Plan.

Termination of employment is based on the definition of no fault termination versus that of fault termination.

The definition of a no-fault termination is the termination of employment of a participant by the company or applicable employer company by reason of:

death;
injury, disability or ill health;
dismissal based on operational requirements as contemplated in the Labour Relations Act No 66 of 1995;
retirement on or after the normal retirement date;
voluntary early retirement in terms of the rules of the retirement plan of which the participant is a member;
the company by which the participant is employed ceasing to be a member of the Tiger Brands group;
mutual agreement between the company and the participant; or
the undertaking in which the participant is employed being transferred to a transferee which is not a member of Tiger Brands.

Under the above circumstances, if employment is terminated on a no-fault basis, then, depending on the nature of the unit (ie whether it is a share appreciation right, performance share or restricted share) and the reasons for termination, a participant may either retain all units or only a pro rata portion of the units. Accelerated vesting and settlement of the retained units may apply in certain circumstances.

The definition of a fault termination is the termination of employment of a participant by reason of dismissal for misconduct or poor performance or a resignation by the participant.

If employment is terminated on a fault basis, the units will be cancelled.

Tiger Brands (1985) Share Option Scheme

Executive directors

Details of equity-settled options issued in terms of the Tiger Brands (1985) Share Option Scheme held by executive directors as at September 2014, together with options exercised during the year, are set out in note 24 of the notes to the annual financial statements. The movement in these options is summarised in the following table:

    Balance at the beginning of the year (Number) Share
options granted
Share
options exercised
Balance
at the end of the year (Number)
Fair market value of outstanding options (R000)  
  Executive director            
  CFH Vaux 23 000 – 23 000 – –  

In addition to the previous table, an executive director previously held options over shares in the Spar Group Limited and Adcock Ingram Holdings Limited. All remaining options over shares in the Spar Group and Adcock Ingram Holdings Limited were exercised by the executive director prior to 30 September 2014. These options were created as part of the Spar and Adcock Ingram unbundling transactions, to ensure that Tiger Brands‘ option holders were treated on a consistent basis with Tiger Brands‘ shareholders following the distribution of Tiger Brands’ investments in those companies.

Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme

Executive directors

Details of phantom cash-settled options held by executive directors under the Tiger Brands Phantom Cash-settled Option Scheme as at 30 September 2014 are set out below:

  Name Date of grant Holding
at
1 October 2013
Granted 2014 Exercised 2014 Forfeited 2014 Holding
at
30 Sep- tember
2014
Number of options subject to retention Number
of options subject to perform- ance
targets
Grant
price
(Rand)
Number of options vested at
30 Sep- tember
2014
Fair
market
value of vested options
at
30 Sep- tember
2014
(R000)
 
  Executive directors                        
  O Ighodaro Feb 2013 3 400 – – – 3 400 1 701 1 699 299,83 – –  
    Feb 2012 18 900 – – – 18 900 9 450 9 450 253,18 – –  
    Jun 2011 21 850 – – 3 641 18 209 10 926 7 283 186,97 3 642 481  
  Total   44 150 – – 3 641 40 509 22 077 18 432   3 642 481  
  PB Matlare Feb 2013 4 400 – – – 4 400 2 200 2 200 299,83 – –  
    Feb 2012 32 800 – – – 32 800 16 401 16 399 253,18 – –  
    Feb 2011 35 300 – – 5 883 29 417 17 651 11 766 189,09 5 884 763  
    Feb 2010 73 200 – 12 200 – 61 000 24 400 36 600 172,07 12 200 1 762  
    Feb 2009 13 468 – 13 468 – – – – 141,91 – –  
  Total   159 168 – 25 668 5 883 127 617 60 652 66 965 – 18 084 2 525  
  CFH Vaux Feb 2013 3 700 – – – 3 700 1 851 1 849 299,83 – –  
    Feb 2012 20 600 – – - 20 600 10 300 10 300 253,18 – –  
    Feb 2011 22 100 – – 3 683 18 417 11 050 7 367 189,09 3 683 478  
    Feb 2010 45 400 – –- – 45 400 22 701 22 699 172,07 15 134 2 186  
    Feb 2009 25 400 – 25 400 – – – – 141,91 – –  
    Apr 2008 29 363 – 29 363 – – – – 106,44 – –  
    Jan 2008 23 920 – 23 920 – – – – 130,59 – –  
  Total   170 483 – 78 683 3 683 88 117 45 902 42 215 – 18 817 2 664  

Prescribed officers

Details of phantom cash-settled options held by prescribed officers under the Tiger Brands Phantom Cash Option Scheme as at 30 September 2014 are set out below:

  Name Date of grant Holding at 1 October 2013 Granted 2014 Exercised 2014 Forfeited 2014 Holding at 30 Sep- tember 2014 Number of options subject to retention Number of options subject to perform- ance targets Grant price (Rand) Number of options vested at 30 Sep- tember 2014 Fair market value of vested options at 30 Sep- tember 2014 (R000)  
  Prescribed officers                        
  NG Brimacombe Various 100 789 – 29 373 3 550 67 866 26 367 41 499 Various – –  
  NP Doyle Various 60 000 – – – 60 000 30 000 30 000 Various – –  
  AG Kirk None – – – – – – – – – –  
  Total   160 789 – 29 373 3 550 127 866 56 367 71 499 Various – –  

Executive committee members (excluding executive directors and prescribed officers)

Aggregated details of phantom cash options held by members of the executive committee, other than the executive directors and prescribed officers above, as at 30 September 2014 are set out below:

  Name Date of
grant
Holding
at
1 October 2013
Granted 2014 Exercised 2014 Forfeited 2014 Holding
at
30 Sep- tember 2
014
Number
of options subject to retention
Number
of options subject to perform- ance
targets
Grant
price
(Rand)
Number
of options vested at
30 Sep- tember
2014
Fair
market
value of vested options
at
30 Sep- tember
2014
(R000)
 
  Total Various 307 638 – 52 571 22 883 232 184 131 310 100 874 Various 66 023 9 641  

Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan

Executive directors

Details of share appreciation rights allocated to executive directors under the Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan as at 30 September 2014 are set out below:

  Name Date
of grant
Holding at
1 October 2013
Granted
2014
Exercised 2014 Forfeited 2014 Holding at
30 September 2014
  Number of options subject to performance targets Grant price (Rand) Number of options vested at 30 September 2014  
  O Ighodaro Feb 2014 – 13 290 – – 13 290   13 290 254,45 –  
  Note 1 Feb 2014 – 5 390 – – 5 390   5 390 254,45 –  
    Sep 2013 21 200 – – – 21 200   21 200 298,67 –  
    Feb 2013 9 500 – – – 9 500   9 500 299,83 –  
  Total   30 700 18 680 – – 49 380   49 380   –  
  PB Matlare Feb 2014 – 20 540 – – 20 540   20 540 254,45 –  
    Feb 2013 16 300   – – 16 300   16 300 299,83 –  
  Total   16 300 20 540 – – 36 840   36 840   –  
  CFH Vaux Feb 2014 – 12 880 – - 12 880   12 880 254,45 –  
  Note 1 Feb 2014 – 5 220 – – 5 220   5 220 254,45 –  
    Feb 2013 10 300 – – – 10 300   10 300 299,83 –  
  Total   10 300 18 100 – – 28 400   28 400   –  

Note 1 – a special retention allocation of share appreciation rights was made on 28 February 2014. These are subject to normal performance and vesting conditions.

Details of performance shares awarded to executive directors under the Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan as at 30 September 2014:

  Name Date
of grant
Holding at
1 October 2013
Granted 2014 Settled
2014
Forfeited 2014 Holding at
30
September 2014
10-day VWAP share
price on grant date
Number of performance shares
vested at
30 September 2014
 
  O Ighodaro Feb 2014   2 860     2 860 254,45 –  
    Feb 2013 2 000 – – – 2 000 299,83 –  
  Total   2 000 2 860 – – 4 860 – –  
  PB Matlare Feb 2014 – 5 140 – – 5 140 254,45 –  
    Feb 2013 4 100 – – – 4 100 299,83 –  
  Total   4 100 5 140 – – 9 240 – –  
  CFH Vaux Feb 2014   2 780     2 780 254,45 –  
    Feb 2013 2 200 – – – 2 200 299,83 –  
  Total   2 200 2 780 – – 4 980 – –  

Prescribed officers

Details of share appreciation rights allocated to prescribed officers under the Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan as at 30 September 2014 are set out below:

  Name Date
of grant
Holding at
1 October 2013
Granted 2014
Note 1
Exercised 2014 Forfeited 2014 Holding at
30 September 2014
Number of options subject to performance targets Grant
price (Rand)
Number of options
vested at
30 September 2014
 
  NG Brimacombe Note 1 Feb 2014 – 5 120 – – 5 120 5 120 254,45 –  
  NG Brimacombe Feb 2014 – 12 640 – – 12 640 12 640 254,45 –  
  NG Brimacombe Sep 2013 20 100 – – – 20 100 20 100 298,67 –  
  NG Brimacombe Feb 2013 10 000 – – – 10 000 10 000 299,83 –  
  NP Doyle Note 1 Feb 2014 – 5 250 – – 5 250 5 250 254,45 –  
  NP Doyle Feb 2014 – 12 950 – – 12 950 12 950 254,45 –  
  AG Kirk Feb 2014 – 11 800 – – 11 800 11 800 254,45 –  

Note 1 – a special retention allocation of share appreciation rights was made on 28 February 2014. These are subject to normal performance and vesting conditions.

Note 2 – N Segoale, previously reported under prescribed officers, is now reported under executive committee members on page 167.

Details of performance shares awarded to prescribed officers under the Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan as at 30 September 2014 are set out below:

  Name Date of
grant
Holding at
1 October 2013
Granted 2014 Settled
2014
Forfeited 2014 Holding at
30 September 2014
10-day VWAP share price on
grant date
Number of performance shares
vested at
30 September 2014
 
  NG Brimacombe Feb 2014 – 2 720 – – 2 720 254,45 –  
  NG Brimacombe Feb 2013 2 200 – – – 2 200 299,83 –  
  NP Doyle Feb 2014 – 2 790 – – 2 790 254,45 –  
  AG Kirk Feb 2014 – 2 540 –- – 2 540 254,45 –  

Note 1 – N Segoale, previously reported under prescribed officers, is now reported under executive committee members on page 167.

Executive committee members (excluding executive directors and prescribed officers)

Aggregated details of share appreciation rights allocated to members of the executive committee, other than the executive directors and prescribed officers above, as at 30 September 2014, are set out below:

    Date
of grant
Holding at
1 October 2013
Granted 2014
Note 1
Exercised 2014 Forfeited 2014 Holding at
30 September 2014
Number of options subject to performance targets Grant
price
(Rand)
Number of options
vested at
30 September 2014
 
                       
  Total for 2014 Feb 2014 – 76 620 – 10 204 66 416 66 416 254,45 –  
  Total for 2013 Feb 2013 33 800 – – 3 764 30 036 30 036 299,83 –  

Note 1 – a special retention allocation of 15 730 share appreciation rights in total was made on 28 February 2014 to four members of the executive committee. In addition, one member of the executive committee received a sign-on allocation of 10 000 share appreciation rights. Both the retention allocation and sign-on allocation are subject to normal performance and vesting conditions.

Aggregated details of performance shares awarded to members of the executive committee, other than the executive directors and prescribed officers above, as at 30 September 2014, are set out below:

    Date of
grant
Holding at
1 October 2013
Granted 2014 Exercised 2014 Forfeited 2014 Holding at
30 September 2014
10-day VWAP
share
price on
grant date
Number of performance shares
vested at
30 September 2014
Fair market value of vested shares
at 30 September 2014
(R000)
 
                       
  Total for 2014 Feb 2014 – 9 690 – 1 197 8 493 254,45 193 93  
  Total for 2013 Feb 2013 6 500 – – 1 100 5 400 299,83 – –  

Black Managers Trusts

The Tiger Brands Black Managers Trust (BMT I) was established in 2005 as part of the company’s Phase I staff empowerment transaction implemented in October 2005. In terms of the BEE Phase I staff empowerment transaction, the allocation of participation rights to black managers will entitle beneficiaries to receive the underlying Tiger shares (and shares in Adcock Ingram on a one-for-one basis) – after making the required capital contributions to the BMT I – at any time after the specified lock-in period, ie from 1 January 2015.

In terms of the Phase 1 transaction, PB Matlare, the Chief Executive Officer of the company, was allocated the rights to 13 500 Tiger shares in July 2008 at an initial notional price of R117,91 per Tiger Brands underlying share. This notional cost will vary over time in terms of a repurchase formula and, when these participation rights are taken up, this will result in the participant being entitled to receive 13 500 Tiger Brands shares, as well as 13 500 Adcock Ingram shares.

In addition, on 31 December 2009, a top-up allocation of rights to 2 763 Tiger Brands shares (and 2 763 Adcock Ingram shares) was awarded by the BMT I to PB Matlare at an initial combined notional price of R122,39 for a Tiger Brands and an Adcock share.

In addition to the above allocations, certain members of the executive committee have also received various allocations from the BMT I. These represent, in aggregate, the rights to 46 526 Tiger Brands shares (and 46 526 Adcock Ingram shares), allocated at an initial combined notional price ranging between R108,42 and R122,39 for a Tiger Brands and an Adcock Ingram share.

The Tiger Brands Black Managers Trust II (BMT II) was established as part of Tiger Brands’ BEE Phase II empowerment transaction that was implemented on 20 October 2009. In terms of this scheme, PB Matlare received an allocation of rights to 16 300 Tiger shares on 31 January 2010 at a notional price of R147,59 per Tiger Brands share. The lock-in period of the BMT II scheme expires on 31 December 2017. In terms of this scheme and as a retention mechanism, PB Matlare also received an allocation of rights to 58 900 Tiger shares on 1 January 2014, at a notional price of R173,76 per Tiger Brands share.

In addition to the above, certain members of the executive committee have also received various allocations from the BMT II. These represent, in aggregate, the rights to 146 692 Tiger Brands shares, allocated at a notional price ranging between R147,59 and R173,76 per Tiger Brands share.

Share dilution limits

In terms of the rules of the Tiger Brands Phantom Cash Option Scheme, at any point in time, the aggregate of the number of phantom shares relating to all unexercised options in terms of the scheme, together with all unexercised options in terms of the Tiger Brands (1985) Share Option Scheme, is limited to 10% of the total issued share capital of the company. As at 30 September 2014, the aggregate number of all outstanding options under the two schemes represented 0,97% (2013: 1,48%) of the company’s total issued share capital.

The maximum aggregate number of shares which may be acquired by participants under the 2013 Share Plan and any other share plan is not to exceed 5 500 000 (five million five hundred thousand) shares; and for any one participant in terms of the 2013 Share Plan and any other share plan is not to exceed 550 000 (five hundred and fifty thousand) shares. In the determination of these limits, shares which have been acquired through the JSE and transferred to participants shall not be taken into account. As at 30 September 2014, the actual number of shares which may be acquired by participants under the 2013 Share Plan and under the Tiger Brands (1985) Share Option Scheme amounts to, in aggregate, 1 486 082 shares (2013: 1 048 900 shares).

Retirement benefits

During the year, the group made contributions on behalf of the executive directors to an umbrella retirement scheme operated by Investment Solutions. The scheme is a defined contribution retirement plan, with the company contributing 15,7% (2013: 15,7%) of gross pensionable remuneration for retirement funding purposes. The cost of these contributions forms a component of the directors’ total remuneration packages. The three prescribed officers are also members of the above-mentioned umbrella retirement scheme.

In addition, four other members of the executive committee participate in the above-mentioned umbrella retirement scheme. The remaining member of the executive committee belongs to the Tiger Brands Management Provident Fund, which is a defined contribution plan. The company contributed on average 16,1% (2013: 15,9%) of gross pensionable remuneration to the Tiger Brands Management Provident Fund for retirement funding purposes.

Details of contributions made during the year ended 30 September 2014 on behalf of executive directors, prescribed officers and other members of the executive committee are set out under note 4.2 of the notes to the annual financial statements.

Other benefits

The executive directors, prescribed officers and other members of the executive committee enjoy various other benefits, including medical aid cover, permanent health insurance, death in service and funeral cover, as well as the entitlement to a travel allowance where applicable. Post-retirement death benefits are also provided in respect of the Company Secretary, Mr IWM Isdale.

The total values of other benefits paid in respect of the executive directors, prescribed officers and other members of the executive committee are set out under note 4.2 of the notes to the annual financial statements.

Executive service contracts

Executive directors, prescribed officers and other members of the executive committee are not employed on fixed-term contracts and have standard employment agreements with current notice periods of either one or three months. The current retirement age is 63 although a retirement age of 65 applies to certain individuals.

Contractual entitlements on termination of employment include, for employees who leave for reasons of retirement or retrenchment, a pro rata short-term incentive payment, subject to the extent of achievement of the relevant financial and strategic performance targets at the end of the financial year and the necessary individual performance agreement being in place for the individual concerned at the date of his or her exit. Such pro rata incentive payment is subject to the relevant employee being in service for a minimum period of three months during the financial year in question. No pro rata bonus is paid for employees who leave other than for reasons of retirement or retrenchment.

The termination rules relating to options issued under the Tiger Brands Phantom Cash Option Scheme and instruments issued under the Tiger Brands Limited 2013 Share Plan are set out on pages 90 to 93. All options issued under the Tiger Brands (1985) Share Option Scheme have vested in full and are therefore not subject to any termination conditions.

On 15 June 1999, Mr IWM Isdale entered into an employment agreement with the company in respect of his services as Company Secretary. The employment agreement is subject to a notice period of not less than three months to be given by either party. The company may elect to make the payment of a cash sum in lieu of notice of termination.

In the event of such termination of employment creating an obligation on the employer to pay severance pay to the individual concerned in terms of the Labour Relations Act 1995, or the Basic Conditions of Employment Act 1997, then the severance package shall be equal to a multiple of monthly remuneration. The multiple applicable to Mr IWM Isdale currently equates to seven months’ remuneration. The multiple is limited to the number of months that remain from the termination date to the date on which the employee reaches his normal retirement age. Mr IWM Isdale's normal retirement date is the end of April 2015. The payment is based on pensionable remuneration plus the value of medical aid, group life and permanent health insurance benefits. In addition, a fixed amount will be payable by the company as compensation for the loss of benefits arising in terms of the company’s post-retirement death benefit scheme.

Succession planning

Development of a formal succession plan for senior and executive management takes place annually. The plan is discussed and approved by the executive committee and submitted to the remuneration and nomination committee for discussion and final approval. The objective is to ensure that immediate succession is in place and also to develop a talent pool with potential for development and future placement. This includes managers at lower levels. The succession planning process includes all of the company’s international businesses.

External company board appointments

Tiger Brands encourages members of the executive committee to consider accepting appropriate opportunities to serve as non-executive directors on the main board or board sub-committees of external companies. Tiger Brands believes this policy encourages members of the executive to broaden their skills base and experience. A formal policy has been adopted in this regard and, in terms thereof, an executive member will be limited to one substantive outside directorship. In terms of the policy, the Chairman of Tiger Brands, as Chairman of the nomination committee, as well as the Chairman of the remuneration committee are required to authorise any such appointment based on a recommendation from the Chief Executive Officer. Directors’ fees paid to executive members by outside companies in terms of the policy may be retained by the individual concerned. Tiger Brands currently has three members of the executive committee serving in the capacity of non-executive directors on the main boards of external companies.

Non-executive directors

Non-executive directors are expected to carry out all the tasks and duties normally associated with the position of a non-executive director as defined by the Companies Act, King III and the memorandum of incorporation of the company. The board and each of its committees have a charter which sets out the responsibilities of the board and its respective committees.

Non-executive directors are expected to provide the organisation with leadership, expertise and knowledge on strategy, enterprise, innovative ideas and to contribute to the business planning of the company.

Non-executive directors are compensated based on their overall contribution and input to the company, and not just for attendance at board and board committee meetings. Consistent non-attendance at meetings, if applicable, will be appropriately handled as part of the company’s board evaluation process. On this basis, non-executive directors receive an annual fee for their services on the board and board committees, rather than a base fee and a separate meeting attendance fee, which is contemplated by King III.

There are no contractual arrangements for compensation for the loss of office. Non- executive directors do not receive short-term incentives nor do they participate in the company’s long-term incentive scheme. The annual fees payable to non-executive directors for the period commencing 1 March 2014 were approved by shareholders on 11 February 2014.

Fees payable to non-executive directors are approved by the shareholders in terms of the company’s memorandum of incorporation. In terms of the company’s memorandum of incorporation, non-executive directors who perform services outside the scope of the ordinary duties of a director may be paid additional remuneration, the reasonable maximum of which is fixed by a disinterested quorum of directors.

The board recommends the fees payable to the non-executive directors for approval by the shareholders at the annual general meeting of the company. Proposals for fees are first prepared by the executive committee for consideration by the remuneration and nomination committee. Following consideration by the remuneration committee, a final recommendation is then made to the board for its consideration prior to being put to the shareholders for approval.

Consideration is given to the increasing levels of responsibility being placed upon directors, as well as to market benchmarks for similar sized companies and projected inflation over the relevant period.

The table below sets out the current and prior year annual fees:

Levels of fees for non-executive directors

For the period 1 March to 28 February (Rand)   2015   2014  
Base fee   323 064   304 777  
Committee chair          
Audit committee   245 528   231 630  
Remuneration committee   183 094   171 940  
Risk and sustainability committee   168 000   148 233  
Social, ethics and transformation committee   139 564   131 664  
Committee membership          
Audit committee   126 055   118 920  
Remuneration committee inclusive of the nomination committee   91 128   85 970  
Risk and sustainability committee   77 850   73 443  
Social, ethics and transformation committee   69 781   65 831  
Chairman’s remuneration   1 500 305   1 415 382  
Deputy Chairman’s remuneration   775 352   731 464  

The Chairman and Deputy Chairman do not receive any additional remuneration for their participation in the sub-committees of the board.

In addition to the above fees, non-executive directors are currently paid an amount of R17 000 per meeting in respect of special meetings of the board and an amount of R3 400 per hour in respect of any additional work undertaken by them, provided that payment in respect of any such additional work is approved by the remuneration and nomination committee and the Chief Executive Officer.

Fees paid to individual non–executive directors for the year ended 30 September 2014 are set out in the table of directors’ emoluments reflected under note 4.2 of the notes to the annual financial statements.

The board, based on the recommendation of the remuneration committee, has determined that shareholders be requested to approve that the various fees payable to non-executive directors, be increased with effect from 1 March 2015. Approval of shareholders will also be sought for increasing the fees paid for attendance at special board meetings and for additional work undertaken by non-executive directors.

Details of the proposed increases are contained in the notice of annual general meeting of shareholders in respect of the shareholder meeting to be held on 9 February 2015. The specific resolutions to be voted on by shareholders in respect of directors’ remuneration increases are special resolutions number 2, 3 and 4.

It is company practice to conduct an external benchmarking exercise on the fees payable to non-executive directors every two years. A market review of non-executive directors’ remuneration was undertaken during 2013 and forms the basis of the proposed increases, effective from 1 March 2015. The current fees have accordingly been adjusted by an inflation-related increase of 6,5% for the year commencing 1 March 2015, subject to shareholder approval.

Board evaluation process

In compliance with various regulatory frameworks (including the JSE Listings Requirements, the Companies Act and King III), the Tiger Brands board and its committees have recently participated in an evaluation exercise through the engagement of an external independent service provider. A well thought-out and comprehensive evaluation process provides the board of directors with the opportunity to enhance performance and to better meet the needs of the company and its stakeholders through:

improved board performance by identifying areas which require attention and training;
confirmation that matters are being discussed and approved in the most appropriate governance forums; and
assessing whether the board, its members and sub-committees are operating optimally.

The board evaluation is intended to contribute towards ensuring that the board of directors is strong, balanced and independent.

The current evaluation process concluded that the board was a high-performing board, although some areas were identified where improvements to the board’s effectiveness could be made, which included the following:

ongoing training in areas relevant to the board, in particular, distinguishing between the roles played by management and the board
enhanced understanding of the company’s operations through more regular site visits
expanding the board by including a director or directors with relevant experience in the key areas of strategic focus outside of South Africa.